The FJMC Sefer Haftarah is at FJMC International Convention in Costa Mesa, CA Next week it will be at Temple Etz Chaim, Thousand Oaks, CA

This week's Unraveller is sponsored In Honor of my husband, Mark, and his outstanding two years as FJMC International President by his wife Leslie Berlin and his son and daughter-in-law, Justin Berlin and Melanie Bernstein.
Yasher Koach, Mark!

This week's special portions in the FJMC Sefer Haftarah scroll, the travelling haftarah scroll which visits a different synagogue each week and contains all of the haftarot has been sponsored by: Beth Emeth Bais Yehuda Brotherhood, Toronto, ON
The Sefer Bamidbar of the Sefer Haftarah is available for sponsorship.

Did you know that the FJMC offers individual Haftarah parshiyot suitable for framing? Click here for the PDF

Use this link when shopping at
All purchases via our Amazon links provide critical support to the FJMC, at no additional cost to you!

For upcoming FJMC events
Visit the FJMC website

The online magazine for Jewish men.
Read it here!

Editorial Board
Rabbi Wayne Allen
Rabbi Leonard S. Berkowitz
Rabbi Paul Drazen
Dr Rela Mintz Geffen
Hazzan Alberto Mizrahi
Rabbi Stephan Parnes

Newsletter Chairmen
David Goldis
Randall Smith

Interested in more weekly newsletters and commentaries? We have compiled a list of other Conservative/Masorti sources. All are free, all are worth reading! Click here
Tell us what you think about this weekly letter.

Looking for an Unraveller?
All previous issues are available online!

Reading someone else's copy? Sign up here for free home delivery!

Don't want to receive the Unraveller any longer? Click here to unsubscribe. Be sure to use the e-mail address where you receive the Unraveller when you reply.


Sponsors needed!

There will be another issue of the Unraveller next week. Help keep The Unraveller going with your sponsorship!

July 9, 2011 / 7 Tammuz, 5771
Shabbat Chapter Two Mishnah Five
Selected Commentary
Rabbi Jay M. Stein

Shabbat 2, 5

  1. One who extinguishes the lamp because of fear of non-Jews, robbers, or an evil spirit, or so that a sick person may sleep, he is exempt.
  2. A person (or, one who) douses the light in order to spare 9save money on) the lamp, the oil, or the wick, he is liable.
    1. Rabbi Yose exempts in all cases, except for the wick, because he makes charcoal.

We tend to live in a world of absolutes. Polarization of politics, religion and society in general seems to be ubiquitous. Extreme perspectives rule the day and there is blurring of lines between news and entertainment, between evaluation and persuasion. Rarely do we consider context or circumstance and often we ascribe cynical intent, imagining the worst of others and suggesting misguided belief systems as their motivation.

This Mishna suggests that is not how the entire system of ritual works. If the Rabbis are truly representing what they believe to be the will of God, they also have faith in God's capacity for seeing the best in everyone. A legal system of absolutes rarely can withstand time and commitment. Our legal system weighs intent as a critical component to evaluating punishment. The only question that remains is what is considered a good reason.

Our Mishna says that it is prohibited to extinguish a lamp on Shabbat. Just as one is not permitted to light a fire on Shabbat, so too one cannot purposefully put one out. Yet there is a disagreement over the intent of the person extinguishing the light. Rabbi Meir/The Prince (the unamed voice in the Mishna and the editor of all the Mishna) suggests one is not held responsible for putting out a lamp for reasons of safety and health. Rabbi Yose is even a little more lenient teaching that one is not held responsible for when issue of preservation of resources is involved. One might even suggest that his approach is teaching us about the health and safety of individuals and of our environment as well.

Whether we ultimately would follow Rabbi Meir or Rabbi Yose, we can derive important principles about the Jewish judicial system and the discretionary responsibility of carrying out the law. Though the Rabbis cannot permit that which is forbidden, they find leniency in sentencing. Understanding that a strict and seemingly impossible standard may turn people off entirely, they Rabbis find some wiggle room within the system in order to be as inclusive as possible keeping the žcommunity of the committedÓ from rejecting the codes entirely. The Rabbis certainly find it within their prerogative to implement the law in ways that keep a spark of commitment alive.

This week's Mishnah lesson was written by
Rabbi Jay M. Stein

Rabbi Jay M. Stein became the Senior Rabbi of Har Zion Temple in Penn Valley, PA in January, 2004. He is a member of the Committee on Jewish Laws and Standards of the Conservative Movement. Currently, he is a Board Member of the Jewish Federation of Greater Philadelphia; an Executive Board Member of Vaad Board of Rabbis, Philadelphia; and a member of the Chancellor's Rabbinic Cabinet of The Jewish Theological Seminary of America. From 1990-1991, Rabbi Stein served as an Alef-Alef Fellow in Jewish Education at Tel Aviv University. In 1993, he was awarded the Lowenfeld Prize in Practical Theology from The Jewish Theological Seminary of America and, in 1995, he was named a Wexner Rabbinic Fellow. He founded a Regional Think Tank for Rabbis serving as Spiritual Leaders in the Solomon Schechter Day Schools. Rabbi Stein authored a chapter in The Resource Guide for Rabbis on Domestic Violence published by Jewish Women International, and co-published articles on domestic violence in the Rabbinical Assembly Newsletter, as well as Outlook Magazine. Presently, Rabbi Stein is a participant of the STAR Rabbis: Good to Great Program and a certified Counselor in Chemical Dependence. He has received his ordination, M.A.; Jewish Education, B.A.; Jewish Philosophy from The Jewish Theological Seminary of America; and B.A., Sociology from Columbia University.

The opinions expressed in this Unraveller are those of the author and do not necessarily represent the FJMC.

Convention 2011
FJMC International Convention 2011
Next convention will be in the summer of 2013. Big announcements on where and when coming soon. Keep reading the Unraveller for further details!

This special mailing from the FJMC is beeing sent to you and the other subscribers of the FJMC's Unraveller as a special promotion. To unsubscribe, simply send an e-mail from the address you wish to unsubscribe, to this address: end-Unraveller@fjmc-consultants.org?subject=Unsubcribe

FOLLOW US ON TWITTER! Unsubscribe here
http://twitter.com/unravellerfjmc This e-mail letter is hosted and distributed by INTERACTIVEPAGES, Toronto